Archived Tweets / Research Data
Codes & Themes w/wo Theoretical Memos
(derived through a process of inductive, qualitative, data analysis)
Archived on 12 February 2023 at 11:00am [URL redacted]
@ScottySturrup [name pseudonymized] [ontology] : @opivali @PapiTrumpo Hey Opivali there is #PanicInDC and you’re on the #LyingTeam #LosingTeam 🤦🏻‍♀️ it’s not my fault. #Trump is fighting for you too. #WakeUp ⏰ #AmericaNeedsYouAwake not #Woke 😇 ❤️ 🇺🇸 100% [URL redacted]
[165]
Archived on 2 December 2022 at 11:00pm [URL redacted]
@TamiaToll [name pseudonymized] [ontology] : #woke [URL redacted]
[400]
Archived on 1 June 2022 at 12:15pm [URL redacted]
@CalebCucinella [name pseudonymized] [ontology] [05]: @starwars It’s not #Lucasfilm’s first claim of a hate conspiracy, Meant to distract from the truth about their product. #woke #obiwan #ObiWanKenobi #DisneyPlus @Disney #StarWars @AP @BoundingComics [URL redacted]
#IRLPoliticalStrategistSteveBannon #WebsiteVDAREPeterBrimelow [The Southern Poverty Law Center] [Wikipedia] #WebsiteVDARE [Wikipedia] #IRLIdeologueMiloYiannopoulosAKAMiloAndreasWagner #BrandTheDailyWirePolemicistBenShapiro #WebsiteVDAREMichaelJThompsonAKAPaulKersey [Muckrack] according to #AdvocacyUSPeopleForTheAmericanWayPFAWRightWingWatch [Wikipedia] "Thompson is just one of many members of the white nationalist movement in the United States that attempted to reinvent its public image with the 'alt-right' moniker and rose to a flash of influence in Republican politics amid the 2016 presidential campaign of​ Donald J. Trump. Leading up to that political moment, a clique of the movement's believers had situated themselves inside GOP-aligned institutions and media outlets in and around Washington, where they used the resources at their disposal to advance their cause. Thompson's career took him inside the Leadership Institute, a pillar of the conservative movement for more than 40 years, and ultimately to the right-wing tabloid-style website, WorldNetDaily. " https://www.peoplefor.org/rightwingwatch/post/hiding-in-plain-sight-the-white-nationalist-who-toiled-inside-a-right-wing-media-powerhouse #PoliticsNationalismWhite #OrgClassifPPUSRepublicanPartyGOPPOTUSDonaldTrump #WebsiteWorldNetDailyWND [Muckrack] #AdvocacyUSNationalPolicyInstituteNPIRichardSpencer #IRLCommentatorDaveRubin #IRLCommentatorMikeCernovich [The Southern Poverty Law Center] #NMUSOneAmericaNewsNetworkOANNJackPosobiec #IRLPsychologistJordanPeterson #IRLShockJockAlexJonesInfoWars #IRLIdeologuePaulJosephWatson #VlogComicArtistProSecretsEthanVanSciver #BrandTimcastMediaGroupTimPool #VlogGeeksPlusGamersJeremyGriggs #VlogTheQuarteringJeremyHambley
Supplementary #WebsiteRewritingRipley.com "We need to talk about the fact that almost 40% of negative YouTube videos mentioning The Last Jedi are from radical right wing or alt right accounts. These accounts have also dedicated their channels to hate campaigns against Captain Marvel star Brie Larson, former SNL cast member Leslie Jones, and feminist YouTuber Anita Sarkeesian. ... Christopher Wylie, a data scientist for Cambridge Analytica, states that Bannon was interested in the firm 'because [Bannon] follows this idea of the Breitbart doctrine, which is that if you want to change politics, you first have to change culture.' He stated that Bannon wanted 'weapons to fight a culture war.'" https://rewritingripley.medium.com/in-plain-sight-how-white-supremacy-misogyny-and-hate-targeted-the-star-wars-sequel-trilogy-and-2fd0be4b242 #2017_StarWarsTheLastJediEpisodeVIII #PoliticsFascismNaziNeoFarRightAltRightRadicalRight #IRLActorBrieLarson #IRLComedianLeslieJones #VlogFeministFrequencyAnitaSarkeesian #IRLActorJohnBoyega #MetaphorWarfareCulture #CampaignHashtagGamerGate #SlurWhiteSupremacy #MagazineVanityFair #BrandCambridgeAnalytica #IRLWhistleblowerChristopherWylie #Website4chan8chan8kun #IRLActorOscarIsaac #IRLActorLupitaNyongO #PoliticsFascismUltraPalingenetic  #_Focal #PhenomnGnothiSeautonACompendiumOf4chansRedpillsAndConspiracyFacts [site archive]
#2025_ #OrgUSTEDTalks #NewspaperUKBrdshtTheObserverCaroleCadwalladr https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TZOoT8AbkNE #CharacterisationTechBro #PoliticsAuthoritarianismAutocracyBroligarchy https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2024/nov/17/how-to-survive-the-broligarchy-20-lessons-for-the-post-truth-world-donald-trump #TauntBigTech #PoliticsFascismTechno #IRLBusinesspersonArronBanks #PoliticsGovernanceOligarchy #IRLScholarTimothySnyder #TauntCatLady #PowerControlStrategicLawsuitsAgainstPublicParticipationSLAPPs #PhenomnCoupDEtatPutsch #TechArtificialIntelligenceAIGenerative #ToponymEuropeGermanyDeutscheDemokratischeRepublikDDR #OrgClassifPPUSRepublicanPartyGOPPOTUSDonaldTrump47thPresident #CatchcryEnemiesOfThePeople [Wikipedia] #MetaphorPlaybook #OrgUSFedGovDepartmentOfGovernmentEfficiencyDOGE
#NewspaperUSBrdshtNewYorkTimesJillLepore "Mr. Musk has long presented himself to the world as a futurist. Yet, notwithstanding the gadgets -- the rockets and the robots and the Department of Government Efficiency Musketeers, carrying backpacks crammed with laptops, dreaming of replacing federal employees with large language models -- few figures in public life are more shackled to the past. On the day of Donald Trump's inauguration, Mr. Musk told a roaring, jubilant crowd that the election marked 'a fork in the road of human civilization.' He promised to 'take DOGE to Mars' and pledged to give Americans reasons to look 'forward to the future.' In 1932, when civilization stood at another fork in the road, the United States chose liberal democracy, and Franklin Roosevelt, who promised 'a new deal for the American people.' In his first 100 days, Mr. Roosevelt. signed 99 executive orders, and Congress passed more than 75 laws, beginning the work of rebuilding the country by establishing a series of government agencies to regulate the economy, provide jobs, aid the poor and construct public works. Mr. Musk is attempting to go back to that fork and choose a different path. Much of what he has sought to dismantle, from antipoverty programs to national parks, have their origins in the New Deal. Mr. Roosevelt's Works Progress Administration provided 8.5 million Americans with jobs; Mr. Musk has measured his achievement by the number of jobs he has eliminated." https://www.nytimes.com/2025/04/04/opinion/elon-musk-doge-technocracy.html #IRLEntrepreneurElonMusk #CharacterisationVisionaryFuturist #MetaphorWarfareHeroMusketeer #OrgClassifPPUSDemocraticPartyPOTUSFranklinDRooseveltFDR #IRLHistoricalFigureJoshuaHaldeman #PoliticsGovernanceTechnocracy #MetaphorDiseaseMindVirus #ToponymAmericaNorthUSCaliforniaNorthernSiliconValley #TauntPresumptionHubris #IRLEntrepreneurMarcAndreessen #TheoryFuturismFilippoTommasoMarinetti #PoliticsAuthoritarianismAutocracy https://www.nytimes.com/2021/11/04/opinion/elon-musk-capitalism.html #NarrativeUtopiaPlacelessness #IRLAuthorDouglasAdams #IRLAuthorHGWells #IRLAuthorIainBanks #WorksSeriesTheCulture #ToponymAfricaSouthernSouthAfrica #BrandAmazonJeffBezos #PowerControlSegregationApartheid #IRLAuthorNovelistUrsulaLeGuin #IRLAuthorVirginiaWoolf
#EpistemologyAmateurExegetePatternSeeking ? #WebsiteSubstackThisWillHold https://substack.com/inbox/post/165658733 #AdvocacyUSFederalistSocietyFedSocLeonardLeo #BrandTrippLite #BrandEatonCorporation #BrandPalantirTechnologies #IRLEntrepreneurPeterThiel #BrandDominionVotingSystems #BrandTechBallotProofEthanShaotran #TechSatelliteTelecommunicationsStarlink #IRLPrivateCitizenCurtisYarvinAKAMenciusMoldbug [Wikipedia] #PhenomnPolicyMedicaid #OrgClassifPPRUSUnitedRussiaVladimirPutin
#EDUCAUniversityOfOttawaRitaAbrahamsen, #EDUCAUniversityOfOttawaMichaelWilliams "Ahmari's essay on dystopia begins by observing that 'Those of us who inhabit the Very Online Right like to point out how this or that new social phenomenon resembles this or that dystopian fiction. ... these resemblances to fictional dystopias should arrest us' (Ahmari 2021). Then he asks, 'What if dystopia is already here? What if our territory already conforms to maps drawn long ago by science-fiction authors? Could it be that we have crossed the invisible frontier that divides an ordinary place, an ordinary topos, from a dystopian realm?' Indeed, Ahmari is effusive in lauding the ability of dystopian fiction to place issues of the day (such as 'cancel culture, woke-ism and gender ideology') within wider frameworks that 'uncover the deeper currents shaping our age.' He sees these contemporary phenomena as 'merely the acceleration of older and deeper processes of ideological transformation' that dystopian fiction can help expose." Abrahamsen, R. and M. C. Williams (2025). 'Radical Right Dystopias in the Global Culture Wars.' Global Studies Quarterly 5(1). [academic source] #AdvocacyUSTheAmericanIdeasInstituteTheAmericanConservativeTACSohrabAhmari [Wikipedia] #MetaphorDissenterVeryOnlineRight #NarrativeUtopiaDystopia #CatchcryCancelCulture #PhenomnDogmaAntiGenderIdeologyGenderismGenderTheory
"Owens, Crowder and Shapiro have all been of great import to the Trump movement. Other figures include - but not limited to - Charlie Kirk, Jesse Kelly, Dan Bongino, Jack Posobiec, Dave Rubin, and even Trump himself. Other figures, such as Joe Rogan, Elon Musk and Tulsi Gabbard, though not of the Right ideologically, can be counted as fellow travelers. Just as how AM radio have been the medium of choice for tech-savvy conservatives during the years of Reagan and Bush, the Internet have been the broadcasting tool for the online Trump supporters. Conservatives' favorite punching bag have been the well-to-do elites from the coasts, who are seen as unattached to a locality. However, by using the Internet, the Very Online Right can broadcast their views from anywhere in the world." https://musicallyspeaking.substack.com/p/the-rise-of-the-very-online-right #IRLCommentatorCandaceOwens #VlogLouderWithCrowderLWCStevenCrowder #TalkbackRadioTheClayTravisAndBuckSextonShow #TalkbackRadioTheJesseKellyShow [Wikipedia] #NMUSFOXFNCDanBongino #NMUSOneAmericaNewsNetworkOANNJackPosobiec #VlogJoeRoganExperienceJRE #IRLEntrepreneurElonMusk #OrgClassifPPUSDemocraticPartyTulsiGabbard
#AdvocacyTurningPointTPUSACharlieKirk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CqU7D_ONJQs&t=1s #CatchcryFreeSpeechFreedomOfSpeech #CatchcryAltRightCounterCulture #CatchcryIdeologicalDiversity #ConspiracyTheory_CulturalMarxism #TheoryMarxism #IdentityConservative #CauseActivismConservative #MetaphorVersusUsThemPatriotismIsLoveCriticismIsHate #EpistemologyAmateurExegeteAutodidact
#IRLAuthorPeterJukes "Viewed against that history, Musk's line about 'abolishing' the EU [tweet] [jpeg] is more than a libertarian thought experiment. It condenses the political slogans of Trumpism and Brexit into one sentence: the nation-state as the only legitimate unit of sovereignty; supranational institutions as inherently undemocratic; the EU as something done to people, not by them. Medvedev's one-word response - 'Exactly' - makes plain how neatly this dovetails with Moscow's long-term ambitions. As former president and now deputy chair of Russia's Security Council, he has become one of the regime's most aggressive public voices, regularly threatening Europe with escalation and calling for a remade world order. When he endorses the abolition of the EU, he is not being rhetorical; he is restating a core Kremlin objective that has underpinned years of covert finance, disinformation and interference. The screenshot collapses those agendas into a single image: a leading Russian official cheerleading the destruction of the EU, and a tech mogul with his hand on the levers of global speech amplifying the same idea." https://pdjukes.substack.com/p/musk-medvedev-and-the-long-war-on #OrgEU #OrgClassifPPRUSUnitedRussiaDmitryMedvedev [tweet] #PhenomnBrexit
#EDUUKUniversityOfGlasgowRebeccaHarrison "Since its rise to power, the First Order has obsessively undermined the ideologies of the former New Republic, which calls to mind Trump repealing Obama-era legislation in areas such as health and welfare. In spreading fear among citizens and dismantling liberal institutions, its leaders also resemble ordinary businessmen and politicians. Where, in The Force Awakens, Kylo harboured fantasies of being the next Darth Vader, here Snoke sneers that he should 'take that ridiculous' mask off. Facing Luke Skywalker in a duel, Kylo also removes his cloak. Dressed in a grey suit, he is less Darth Vader and more Donald Trump Jr. The First Order's arch enemy, General Leia Organa, meanwhile stands in for Hillary Clinton - another woman with too little support for her political agenda, with the air of a lost cause, whose loyalists happen to be much more ethnically diverse than their opponents. This latter difference is thrown into sharp relief when the white Captain Phasma attempts to destroy Finn and Rose, two Resistance fighters of colour, calling them 'scum'. Not overt racism, but reminiscent of a US administration that has advocated racist policies." https://theconversation.com/the-last-jedi-latest-star-wars-is-a-fable-for-our-post-truth-times-89256 #FictionalCharacterStarWarsDarthVader #FictionalCharacterStarWarsSupremeLeaderSnoke [Wikipedia] #IRLBusinesspersonDonaldTrumpJr #FictionalCharacterStarWarsPrincessLeia #OrgClassifPPUSDemocraticPartyHillaryClinton #FictionalCharacterStarWarsCaptainPhasma [Wikipedia] #FictionalCharacterStarWarsFinn [Wikipedia] #FictionalCharacterStarWarsRoseTico [Wikipedia]
#MagazineUSMotherJonesAnnaMerlan "Last week, conservative influencer Isabel Brown celebrated 100 episodes of her podcast, where she sings the praises of motherhood, frets about the dangers of open borders, and asks rhetorical questions about homosexuality and what she frequently terms 'radical' Islam. To celebrate, Brown had a party thrown by the Daily Wire, the right-wing site that hosts her podcast. The event was also sponsored by Meta, the mega-company that owns Facebook, Instagram, and Threads, among other sites. The decorations included an archway that read 'Seeking Truth to Save The West,' underneath the words 'Presented by Meta' and the company's logo. An Instagram post from Brown celebrating the party thanked 'my amazing team at the Daily Wire and our friends at Meta for throwing me the cutest 'save the west' party right in the heart of dc,' and reiterated that the tech company had made 'this special celebration possible.'" https://www.motherjones.com/politics/2026/04/isabel-brown-show-meta-islam/ #BrandTheDailyWirePolemicistIsabelBrown [digital archives] #BrandTechMetaMarkZuckerberg #PhenomnSexualityHomosexuality #CharacterisationRadicalFundamentalismIslamic
[5837]
Archived on 20 January 2022 at 9:30pm [URL redacted]
@MaureenGawrych [name pseudonymized] [ontology] : #altrightplaybook #woke [URL redacted]
#MetaphorWarfareSocialJusticeWarriorSJW #PoliticsFascismNazi #PowerControlPopulationEugenics #ConspiracyTheory_CabalGroomingGang #LiteralSchoolCollegeUniversity #MetaphorDeceitLugenpresseMainstreamMediaMSM #EpistemologyAmateurExegeteAutodidact
Context "People from marginalized groups are often asked insensitive personal questions by members of privileged groups. These questions often come with an entitled subtext that it is somehow the duty of the marginalized person to explain things on behalf of the group they belong to. 'It's not my job to educate you' has developed as a standard response to that kind to invasive and entitled questioning." https://medium.com/@classylore/on-terms-its-not-my-job-to-educate-you-1bace85ddd74 #PowerControlMicrofascismGoEducateYourself
[951]
Archived on 26 December 2021 at 2:45pm [URL redacted]
@EdenPoinsett [name pseudonymized] [ontology] : #woke #neomulticulturalism #multiculturalism [URL redacted]
"The reason I am alternative, and I must make the distinction that I don't mean alt-right, is that I was not provided a sufficient education when I was young and was in a position where I felt rebellious to that fact. My response focused on what I noticeably thrived at or enjoyed. In doing this, I began educating myself alternatively and without knowing it at the time. Most White people take in the same or similar curriculums. The mass idiocy at a certain point becomes no surprise, when you go deeper beyond what they tell you is foundational. You will most likely be punished for it at some end, though, and perhaps often." #EpistemologyAmateurExegeteAutodidact ? #PleaNeutrality
[102]
Archived on 1 September 2021 at 3:00pm [URL redacted]
@ShawnaTonti [name pseudonymized] [ontology] : When I say I'm #woke this is what I mean [URL redacted]
[55]
Archived on 3 June 2021 at 3:15pm [URL redacted]
@GraceLoud [name pseudonymized] [ontology] : Note to all: Confusing Academic Achievement with Knowledge/Education is like confusing bacon fat with beet juice. Critical thought, it's what the "cool" kids are doing now. #woke #liberal #minion #Democrats #russia [URL redacted]
President-elect #OrgClassifPPUSRepublicanPartyGOPPOTUSDonaldTrump greets House Minority Leader #OrgClassifPPUSDemocraticPartyNancyPelosi, D-Calif., and other Congressional leaders as he arrives for his inauguration ceremony at the Capitol in Washington, USA on January 20, #2017_. (Photo by J. Scott Applewhite / Pool / AP/Anadolu Agency/Getty Images). #MetaphorConformitySheepSheeple
[900]
Archived on 7 January 2021 at 7:45am [URL redacted]
@LaylaBoyce [name pseudonymized] [ontology] [13]: Gods and Robots: Ancient Dreams of Technology | Adrienne Mayor [URL redacted] #tartarian #tartar #tartary #hidden #wakeup #truth #Tartaria #Autodidactic #woke #freethinker #mudflood #greatrest #selftaught #knowledge #Esoteric @RichGangGeorge
[40]
Archived on 28 December 2020 at 12:00am [URL redacted]
@LaylaBoyce [name pseudonymized] [ontology] [13]: David Icke The Living Consciousness and The Control of Reality [URL redacted] #tartarian #tartar #tartary #hidden #wakeup #truth #Tartaria #Autodidactic #woke #freethinker #mudflood #greatrest #selftaught #knowledge
[20]
Archived on 15 November 2020 at 10:00am [URL redacted]
@LaylaBoyce [name pseudonymized] [ontology] [13]: Canada, Tartaria, Mud Floods, Live Chat Series with The Mad Watcher [URL redacted] #tartarian #tartar #tartary #hidden #wakeup #truth #Tartaria #Autodidactic #woke #freethinker #mudflood #greatrest
#VlogTheMadWatcher https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9qJd90yEimw&t=185s #VlogAutoDidacticCambellPurvis #ToponymAmericaNorthCanada #ToponymOceaniaAustraliaWAPerth #1851_TheGreatExhibitionTheCrystalPalace #PhenomnVirusCOVID19PandemicMitigationLockdown #ConspiracyTheory_COVID19PandemicDenialHoax
Context #ConspiracyTheory_TartarianEmpire i.e. "the pseudohistorical 'nation' of Tartaria has developed a cult following on social media. Supposedly, this country was a grand and culturally-rich empire, found in the area today recognised as Central Asia and parts of Europe. More fantastical strands of the theory add suggestions of Tartaria's advanced technology, Tartarian buildings buried under modern cities as far as North America, or its population of giants. Believers seek 'evidence' for its existence in seemingly mismatched architecture found across Europe and Asia, as well as references to 'Tartary' or 'Tartaria' on historical maps. Historians have since explained this to be a name given to various regional ethnic groups by outsiders. The theory concludes with the view that modern European powers conspired to cover up Tartaria, which was destroyed in a mud flood, and replace the idyllic civilisation with a globalised, degenerated society that they could control. ... Tartaria, as harmless as it may seem, has been used by Russian ethnonationalists to support an expansion of Russian land and the supposed 'supremacy' of Russians. Pseudohistory has been historically deployed by extremists to justify reclaiming certain areas and expelling others, oftentimes accompanied by suggestions of ethnic or racial 'purity'." https://gnet-research.org/2023/02/15/the-dangers-of-pseudohistorical-conspiracy-theories/, which references Abbie Richards' [Wikipedia] 'interactive conspiracy chart': https://conspiracychart.com/ #PoliticsNationalismRussian #PoliticsNationalismEthno #BeliefPseudosciencePseudohistory
Supplementary #MagazineUSPopMattersRobHorning "The Internet has ushered in something of a golden age for autodidacts, because it provides both the free information and the sheltered universe necessary for autodidacts to thrive. Autodidacticism does not purify education; it's just self-protection. And it easily slips into dilettantism, where one explores a subject only up to the point where it requires some discipline. Autodidacticism is probably as much about miserliness and fear as it is about curiosity -- it's often an attempt to amass a kind of theoretical power from knowledge while preventing oneself from ever having any occasion to test it. It's an expression of a fantasy about knowledge -- that it is not socially created but is instead laden with inherent value, like gold, and can be possessed and cherished in isolation. Autodidacts withdraw knowledge from the social circuits and contexts that make it useful and meaningful -- that facilitate the exchange and syntheses that produce knowledge -- and hoard it, using it to seal themselves off completely from the judgments [sic] of peers" (31 October #2006_). https://www.popmatters.com/the-dangers-of-autodidacticism-2495732019.html #MetaphorDissenterRebelOutsider #EpistemologyAmateurExegeteAutodidactDilettantism
And #MagazineUS3QuarksDailyJustinSmith "why, oh why, would anyone choose the parasitic social role of the self-trained loner philosopher, who enjoys none of the social capital of the professional, and who inevitably will be unable to communicate with anyone whose opinion carries any weight at all in society, never having learned the appropriate behavioral and lexical cues that make communication possible? What are the social factors that make these men (and they are always men) possible?" (30 October 2006). https://3quarksdaily.com/3quarksdaily/2006/10/selected_minor_-6.html
Addendum #EpistemologyAmateurExegeteAutodidact (self-taught) advocate (in this case presumably, educated through watching #PhenomnPodcastVideo.s presented by other #CharacterisationYouTuber.s). #TheoryAlternativeHistory #TheoryRomanticismExistingOutsideOfCulture #EpistemologyAmateurExegeteAutodidactDigital
[303]
Archived on 22 September 2020 at 5:45pm [URL redacted]
@JeniferDings [name pseudonymized] [ontology] : Get well soon JP #jordanpeterson #12rulesoflife #intersection #intersectionalism #intersectionality #communism #marxism #politics #philosphy #learning #intelligence #thinking #thinker #science #woke #feminism [URL redacted]
#2018_12RulesForLifeAnAntidoteToChaos [Wikipedia] #PoliticsCommunism #TheoryMarxism #CauseFeminism "politics philosphy [sic] learning intelligence thinking thinker science" #EpistemologyAmateurExegeteAutodidact ?
Supplementary #VlogSamVaknin [channel] "try to argue with a fan of Jordan Peterson, see what you get. These are cults. Try to argue with someone who believes in the idiotic QAnon, see what you get. These are all cults. With varying degrees of intelligence, the adherence of QAnon are at the lower rank of the ladder of intellect, obviously, and the followers of Jordan Peterson are higher up, but they're all cults. So of course in cults, the main function of a cult is to reduce anxiety, to reduce worry by introducing rigid rules, which if you follow, you are guaranteed to acquire magical powers, influence on the world." https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mJTA3Vno8LU&t=1699s
Addendum criticism that #TheorySociologyIntersectionality will inevitably lead to further 'individualisation' i.e. #TheoryMarginalisation can be understood in terms of #IRLSociologistAndreasReckwitz's characterisation of the divide between #TheoryIndividualismSelfActualisation, which is characteristic of what Reckwitz defines as #TheoryHyperculture versus the impulses of what he defines as #TheoryCulturalEssentialism (which he explains is deeply invested in #TheoryCulturalEssentialismRegulatedCollective).
[1319]