Archived Tweets / Research Data
Codes & Themes w/wo Theoretical Memos
(derived through a process of inductive, qualitative, data analysis)
@JoleneSkean [name pseudonymized] [ontology] : Hey #Woke:
Müssen wir hier nicht über "kulturelle Aneignung" sprechen, wenn aus selbem Grund Weiße keine Rastas tragen sollen?
Nein, müssen wir nicht! Merkt ihr selbst, oder?
#Oktoberfest2022 #FCBayern [URL redacted]
"Hey Woke :
Shouldn't we be talking about 'cultural appropriation' here if, for the same reason, white people shouldn't wear Rastas?
No, we don't have to! You see it yourself, don't you?
Oktoberfest2022 FCBayern" #PhenomnCulturalAppropriation
#EventOktoberfest #ToponymEuropeGermanyBavariaMunich #OrgDEFssballClubBayernMunchen [Wikipedia] 'Rastas' = #SymbolHairstyleDreadlocks ?
this sets out a #ReasoningFallacyWhataboutism based on a #PoliticsNationalismEthno assumption that being #ToponymEuropeGermanyBavaria.n necessitates that you're white. The logic follows, that if #IdentityBlack people are not criticised for dressing 'white', then #IdentityWhite people shouldn't be criticised for their #PhenomnCulturalAppropriation of the cultures of others. Significantly, #IRLSportspersonDayotUpamecano is French i.e. "is a French professional footballer who plays as a centre-back for Bundesliga club Bayern Munich and the France national team" [Wikipedia] Given this, cultural appropriation tends to have an 'exploitative' dimension to it i.e. that those appropriating tend to be doing so to gain advantage (from those whose culture is being appropriated) - so, in the sense, any such appropriation would be deemed trivial (surely).
[318]
@JuanitaMantle [name pseudonymized] [ontology] : @welt Richtig, denn so darf und soll sich jeder kleiden/stylen dürfen wie er will. Man stelle sich vor, es würde ein Erlass geben, dass Trachten nur noch von weißen Deutschen/Bayern angezogen werden dürfen. Wäre das auch #woke? Ich denke nicht. [URL redacted]
"That's right, because everyone can and should be allowed to dress/style themselves as they want. Imagine if there were a decree that traditional costumes could only be worn by white Germans/Bavarians. Would that also be woke ? I do not think so."
Addendum this sets out a #ReasoningFallacyWhataboutism based on a #PoliticsNationalismEthno assumption that being German/Bavarian necessitates that you're white. The logic follows, that if #IdentityBlack people are not criticised for dressing 'white', then #IdentityWhite people shouldn't be criticised for their #PhenomnCulturalAppropriation of the cultures of others. Significantly, #IRLSportspersonDavidAlaba is Austrian (born in #ToponymEuropeAustriaVienna ) and #IRLCampaignManagerShalimarHeppner is German (born in Bavaria's capital city, #ToponymEuropeGermanyBavariaMunich ) i.e. neither are positioned 'outside' of the culture they're presenting here (and so, by definition they're not appropriating #ToponymEuropeGermanyBavaria.n culture).
Addendum this sets out a #ReasoningFallacyWhataboutism based on a #PoliticsNationalismEthno assumption that being German/Bavarian necessitates that you're white. The logic follows, that if #IdentityBlack people are not criticised for dressing 'white', then #IdentityWhite people shouldn't be criticised for their #PhenomnCulturalAppropriation of the cultures of others. Significantly, #IRLSportspersonDavidAlaba is Austrian (born in #ToponymEuropeAustriaVienna ) and #IRLCampaignManagerShalimarHeppner is German (born in Bavaria's capital city, #ToponymEuropeGermanyBavariaMunich ) i.e. neither are positioned 'outside' of the culture they're presenting here (and so, by definition they're not appropriating #ToponymEuropeGermanyBavaria.n culture).
#SymbolTrachtLederhosen
#SymbolTrachtDirndl
Context https://www.alamy.de/munchen-bayern-07-okt-2018-david-alaba-und-seine-freundin-shalimar-heppner-der-kafer-zelt-auf-dem-oktoberfest-auf-der-theresienwiese-spieler-trainer-und-manager-des-fussball-erstligisten-fc-bayern-traditionell-besuchen-sie-die-kafer-zelt-zusammen-einmal-wahrend-des-oktoberfestes-credit-matthias-balkdpaalamy-leben-nachrichten-image221438115.html #2018_ #EventOktoberfest
Context https://www.alamy.de/munchen-bayern-07-okt-2018-david-alaba-und-seine-freundin-shalimar-heppner-der-kafer-zelt-auf-dem-oktoberfest-auf-der-theresienwiese-spieler-trainer-und-manager-des-fussball-erstligisten-fc-bayern-traditionell-besuchen-sie-die-kafer-zelt-zusammen-einmal-wahrend-des-oktoberfestes-credit-matthias-balkdpaalamy-leben-nachrichten-image221438115.html #2018_ #EventOktoberfest
[341]
"Is this cultural appropriation? Yes / No" #PhenomnCulturalAppropriation #IRLModelSephoraGoignan and #IRLSportspersonKingsleyComan #EventOktoberfest
#SymbolTrachtLederhosen [Wikipedia]
#SymbolTrachtDirndl
Addendum first of all, are the Goignans German or not i.e. are they 'inside' or 'outside' the culture they're referencing? While there are clearly nuances to this, I think it would be safe to say that the meme's intention is to evoke a #PoliticsNationalismEthno position i.e. that being black disqualifies you from being German (that Germans are ethnically homogeneous). As per the above question, "Kingsley Junior Coman is a French professional footballer who plays as a winger for Bundesliga club Bayern Munich and the France national team" and Sephora is Canadian i.e. neither are German - both are 'outside' the culture they're referencing in this image. This said, cultural appropriation tends to have an 'exploitative' dimension to it i.e. that those appropriating tend to be doing so to gain advantage (from those whose culture is being appropriated) - so, in the sense, any such appropriation would be deemed trivial (surely). #ToponymEuropeGermanyBavaria.n costume.
Addendum first of all, are the Goignans German or not i.e. are they 'inside' or 'outside' the culture they're referencing? While there are clearly nuances to this, I think it would be safe to say that the meme's intention is to evoke a #PoliticsNationalismEthno position i.e. that being black disqualifies you from being German (that Germans are ethnically homogeneous). As per the above question, "Kingsley Junior Coman is a French professional footballer who plays as a winger for Bundesliga club Bayern Munich and the France national team" and Sephora is Canadian i.e. neither are German - both are 'outside' the culture they're referencing in this image. This said, cultural appropriation tends to have an 'exploitative' dimension to it i.e. that those appropriating tend to be doing so to gain advantage (from those whose culture is being appropriated) - so, in the sense, any such appropriation would be deemed trivial (surely). #ToponymEuropeGermanyBavaria.n costume.
[151]